<p>The error occurs when ALTER TABLE tries to add an AUTO_INCREMENT column without acquiring the required table lock.</p>
<p>MySQL Error 1854: ER_ALTER_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED_REASON_AUTOINC means the server blocked your ALTER TABLE because adding an AUTO_INCREMENT column needs an exclusive table lock. Obtain an explicit LOCK TABLES write lock or recreate the table with the column and copy data to resolve the issue.</p>
Adding an auto-increment column requires a lock
Error 1854 appears with the message "Adding an auto-increment column requires a lock" when ALTER TABLE attempts to add an AUTO_INCREMENT column without the exclusive lock MySQL needs to maintain sequence integrity.
The condition ER_ALTER_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED_REASON_AUTOINC was introduced in MySQL 5.7.1 to protect data consistency during DDL changes that affect row ordering.
The root cause is issuing ALTER TABLE ... ADD COLUMN ... AUTO_INCREMENT on a live table that still permits concurrent reads or writes. MySQL refuses the change because it cannot guarantee correct auto-increment sequencing without blocking other sessions.
This happens more often on InnoDB tables running in online DDL mode, where many alterations are normally non-blocking. AUTO_INCREMENT is an exception that always needs a metadata lock.
Acquire an explicit write lock before altering the table so MySQL can safely rebuild the auto-increment values.
Alternatively, create a new table with the AUTO_INCREMENT column defined from the start, copy data across, then swap tables. This method avoids long blocking on large datasets.
Applications that run migration scripts during business hours often hit this error. Insert an explicit LOCK TABLES statement in the migration or schedule the change during low-traffic windows.
CI/CD pipelines may rely on ALGORITHM=INPLACE. Remove that clause and allow MySQL to choose COPY, which implicitly obtains the necessary lock.
Always design primary keys as AUTO_INCREMENT at table creation time if you need them later. Planning schema evolution prevents disruptive DDL changes.
If retrofitting AUTO_INCREMENT is unavoidable, execute the change inside a maintenance window or during transactional downtime managed by orchestration tools like pt-online-schema-change or gh-ost.
Error 1847 (ER_ALTER_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED_REASON_FK_RENAME) blocks renaming columns referenced by foreign keys; drop or disable the FK first.
Error 1846 (ER_ALTER_OPERATION_NOT_SUPPORTED_REASON_DUP_INDEX) stops creating duplicate indexes; check existing indexes before adding new ones.
Active inserts prevent MySQL from locking the table, triggering the error.
Developers assume ALGORITHM=INPLACE covers all cases, but AUTO_INCREMENT always needs a copy or lock.
Long-running locks are unacceptable in production, so MySQL aborts the operation.
Occurs when trying to rename a column referenced by a foreign key without dropping the constraint first.
Raised when attempting to create an index that duplicates an existing one on the same columns.
Happens if you add an AUTO_INCREMENT column while another PRIMARY KEY already exists.
No. MySQL still requires a metadata lock when adding AUTO_INCREMENT, so the operation may switch to COPY or fail with Error 1854.
Yes, but you must lock the table or use a copy method to protect sequence generation during the change.
The tool minimizes but does not eliminate downtime; a brief metadata lock occurs when swapping tables, usually milliseconds.
Galaxy highlights DDL statements that require locks and suggests safe migration patterns in its AI copilot, reducing unexpected runtime errors.
.avif)
.avif){kind=logo}
