Common SQL Errors

MySQL Error 1399 ER_XAER_RMFAIL: XAER_RMFAIL - How to Fix Global Transaction State Issues

Galaxy Team
August 7, 2025

<p>MySQL Error 1399 (ER_XAER_RMFAIL) occurs when an XA command is issued while the global transaction manager reports the resource manager in an invalid state.</p>

Sign up for the latest in common SQL errors from the Galaxy Team!
Welcome to the Galaxy, Guardian!
You'll be receiving a confirmation email

Follow us on twitter :)
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

What is MySQL Error 1399 (ER_XAER_RMFAIL)?

<p>MySQL Error 1399: ER_XAER_RMFAIL signals that the XA resource manager failed - the server cannot run the requested XA command because the global transaction is in an incompatible state. Re-synchronizing or rolling back the XA transaction, then retrying the command, resolves the issue.</p>

Error Highlights

Typical Error Message

XAER_RMFAIL: The command cannot be executed when global

Error Type

Transaction Error

Language

MySQL

Symbol

ER_XAER_RMFAIL

Error Code

1399

SQL State

XAE07

Explanation

Table of Contents

What is MySQL Error 1399 (ER_XAER_RMFAIL)?

MySQL raises Error 1399 with message "XAER_RMFAIL: The command cannot be executed when global transaction is in the %s state" during distributed (XA) transactions. The server rejects the command because the internal resource manager is not ready for the requested operation.

The error usually appears on XA START, XA END, XA PREPARE, XA COMMIT, or XA ROLLBACK statements when the transaction manager detects that the global transaction has drifted into an unexpected state such as PREPARED, HEURISTIC, or ROLLBACK_ONLY.

What Causes This Error?

Mismatch between the transaction state stored in the binary log or InnoDB engine and the state expected by the XA command will raise XAER_RMFAIL. Network splits, crashed sessions, or abrupt client disconnects often leave the transaction half-open.

Replication or failover can also desynchronize the global transaction table. When the same XID is reused or referenced on a different node, MySQL notices the conflict and rejects the operation to protect ACID guarantees.

How to Fix MySQL Error 1399

First, query the INFORMATION_SCHEMA.INNODB_TRX and performance_schema.xa_transactions tables to confirm the current state of the XID. If the transaction is stuck in PREPARED, issue an explicit XA ROLLBACK to clear it.

If the XID is missing, manually remove the orphaned record from the binary log using mysqlbinlog or restart MySQL with innodb_force_recovery=3 to purge corrupted XA entries. Always back up before manual intervention.

Common Scenarios and Solutions

Stale XID after client crash - Roll back the XID, then retry the workload from a clean connection. This frees locks and resets the resource manager.

Duplicate XID on replicated nodes - Ensure GTID replication or binary log shipping copies the entire XA lifecycle. Avoid reusing XIDs in application code.

Best Practices to Avoid This Error

Commit or roll back every XA transaction in application logic. Implement timeouts that safely roll back abandoned XIDs.

Monitor xa_transactions for PREPARED rows. Galaxy's query scheduler can run a health check that alerts engineers when transactions linger beyond a threshold.

Related Errors and Solutions

Error 1397 ER_XA_RMERR - Indicates a different resource manager failure; review engine logs for the root cause.

Error 1400 ER_XAER_NOTA - The specified XID is unknown; verify the XID string and transaction lifecycle.

Common Causes

Aborted Client Session

A client disconnects after XA PREPARE, leaving the XID in PREPARED state. Subsequent XA COMMIT fails with XAER_RMFAIL.

Replication Lag

Binary log replay on a replica finds an XA COMMIT before the corresponding XA PREPARE, causing a state mismatch.

Crash Recovery

The server crashes between XA END and XA PREPARE. On restart, the transaction table is incomplete and any further XA command fails.

Manual XID Reuse

An application mistakenly reuses an XA XID that still exists in PREPARED state, triggering resource manager failure.

Related Errors

MySQL Error 1397 ER_XA_RMERR

General resource manager error during an XA operation; indicates internal engine failure rather than state conflict.

MySQL Error 1400 ER_XAER_NOTA

The specified XID does not exist, commonly raised when applications send XA COMMIT for an unstarted transaction.

MySQL Error 1401 ER_XAER_INVAL

Invalid XA command parameters; check XID format, flags, and SQL syntax.

FAQs

Does XAER_RMFAIL affect non-XA transactions?

No. The error only impacts distributed XA transactions. Standard Autocommit or START TRANSACTION workflows proceed normally.

Can I safely kill the thread holding the PREPARED XID?

Killing the connection frees locks but leaves the XID in limbo. Always use XA ROLLBACK to maintain consistency.

How does Galaxy help me avoid XAER_RMFAIL?

Galaxy surfaces long running PREPARED XA transactions in an editor widget, allowing quick rollback commands and collaborative review before errors escalate.

Is innodb_force_recovery necessary?

Only use innodb_force_recovery as a last resort when InnoDB fails to start because of corrupted XA tables. Always back up first.

Start Querying with the Modern SQL Editor Today!
Welcome to the Galaxy, Guardian!
You'll be receiving a confirmation email

Follow us on twitter :)
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Check out some other errors

Trusted by top engineers on high-velocity teams
Aryeo Logo
Assort Health
Curri
Rubie Logo
Bauhealth Logo
Truvideo Logo