Common SQL Errors

MySQL Error 1334: ER_SP_CANT_ALTER - How to Fix Stored Routine Alteration Failures

Galaxy Team
August 6, 2025

Error 1334 occurs when MySQL cannot complete an ALTER PROCEDURE or ALTER FUNCTION statement because of missing privileges, active locks, or blocking dependencies.

Sign up for the latest in common SQL errors from the Galaxy Team!
Welcome to the Galaxy, Guardian!
You'll be receiving a confirmation email

Follow us on twitter :)
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

What is MySQL error 1334 (ER_SP_CANT_ALTER)?

MySQL Error 1334 (ER_SP_CANT_ALTER) happens when the server cannot run ALTER PROCEDURE or ALTER FUNCTION due to privileges, locks, or dependencies. End running sessions, grant ALTER ROUTINE, or remove dependent objects to resolve the error.

Error Highlights

Typical Error Message

Failed to ALTER %s %s

Error Type

DDL Error

Language

MySQL

Symbol

ER_SP_CANT_ALTER

Error Code

1334

SQL State

HY000

Explanation

Table of Contents

What is MySQL error 1334 (ER_SP_CANT_ALTER)?

MySQL raises Error 1334 with the message “Failed to ALTER %s %s” when it cannot alter a stored procedure or function. The failure generally stems from permission issues, object locks, or dependencies that prevent the definition from changing.

The error stops deployment scripts and CI pipelines because the requested DDL change never executes. Fixing it quickly keeps releases and migrations on track.

What Causes This Error?

Lack of the ALTER ROUTINE or SUPER privilege blocks routine changes. MySQL must verify that the definer or invoker holds the required rights before rewriting the mysql.proc data dictionary.

Active calls to the routine place metadata locks that make the definition temporarily immutable. Long-running connections in production frequently trigger this situation.

Dependent objects such as triggers, events, or other routines referencing the target routine may also block an ALTER if the change would invalidate those dependencies.

How to Fix MySQL Error 1334

First confirm that your account has ALTER ROUTINE on the routine’s database or global SUPER. Grant the privilege if it is missing, then retry the ALTER statement.

If locks are the issue, identify sessions using SHOW PROCESSLIST or performance_schema metadata_lock_info and terminate or wait for them to finish before re-running the DDL.

When dependencies cause the error, drop or alter the referencing triggers, events, or routines, or adjust your ALTER statement to maintain the signature they expect.

Common Scenarios and Solutions

CI/CD pipelines that open an unconditional ALTER PROCEDURE often fail because read-only replica sessions still execute the old version. Schedule the migration during a maintenance window and drain traffic first.

Developers using GUI clients sometimes forget to switch to an account with ALTER ROUTINE. Switching credentials or granting the privilege immediately removes the blocker.

Best Practices to Avoid This Error

Always test routine changes in staging with realistic traffic to uncover locking issues early. Use performance_schema to measure lock wait times during rehearsal.

Adopt versioned routines. Create a new procedure with a suffixed name, migrate callers, then drop the old one. This blue-green method eliminates in-place ALTER statements.

Galaxy’s dependency explorer shows which objects call a routine before you run ALTER, reducing the risk of runtime surprises.

Related Errors and Solutions

Error 1419 (ER_SP_NO_DROP_SP): MySQL blocks dropping a routine created by another user without SUPER. Solution - grant right or change definer.

Error 1235 (ER_UNSUPPORTED_PS): Trying to prepare a statement that includes unsupported SQL. Solution - rewrite query or upgrade MySQL.

Error 1064 (ER_PARSE_ERROR): General syntax error in DDL. Solution - correct SQL syntax.

Common Causes

Missing ALTER ROUTINE Privilege

The connected MySQL user does not have ALTER ROUTINE or SUPER, so the server refuses to modify the routine.

Routine Currently Running

One or more sessions are executing the target procedure or function, holding metadata locks that block the ALTER.

Blocking Dependencies

Triggers, events, or other routines reference the routine. MySQL cannot guarantee integrity after the change, so it rejects the ALTER.

Replication Metadata Locks

On replicas, SQL thread metadata locks may hold the routine open while applying relay log events, stopping your manual ALTER.

Related Errors

Error 1419 - ER_SP_NO_DROP_SP

Occurs when attempting to DROP a routine created by another user without proper privilege. Grant the DROP ROUTINE right or change the routine definer.

Error 1235 - ER_UNSUPPORTED_PS

Raised when a prepared statement uses unsupported SQL constructs. Rewrite the query or upgrade MySQL to a version that supports it.

Error 1064 - ER_PARSE_ERROR

Generic SQL syntax error. Review the failing statement for typos, misplaced delimiters, or missing keywords.

FAQs

Does ALTER ROUTINE require a server restart?

No restart is needed. The change is applied instantly once locks clear and privileges are valid.

Can I force an ALTER while sessions are running?

You cannot bypass metadata locks. End or wait for active sessions, then retry the ALTER.

Will replication break after fixing Error 1334?

Routine changes replicate normally if the same privileges exist on replicas. Always deploy privilege grants alongside DDL to replicas.

How does Galaxy help prevent this error?

Galaxy shows privilege gaps and running sessions in its sidebar before executing ALTER statements, letting engineers address blockers proactively.

Start Querying with the Modern SQL Editor Today!
Welcome to the Galaxy, Guardian!
You'll be receiving a confirmation email

Follow us on twitter :)
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Check out some other errors

Trusted by top engineers on high-velocity teams
Aryeo Logo
Assort Health
Curri
Rubie Logo
Bauhealth Logo
Truvideo Logo